/* * Copyright (c) 2017 The WebRTC project authors. All Rights Reserved. * * Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license * that can be found in the LICENSE file in the root of the source * tree. An additional intellectual property rights grant can be found * in the file PATENTS. All contributing project authors may * be found in the AUTHORS file in the root of the source tree. */ #include "audio/transport_feedback_packet_loss_tracker.h" #include #include #include #include #include "modules/rtp_rtcp/include/rtp_rtcp_defines.h" #include "modules/rtp_rtcp/source/rtcp_packet/transport_feedback.h" #include "rtc_base/checks.h" #include "test/gmock.h" #include "test/gtest.h" namespace webrtc { namespace { constexpr int64_t kDefaultSendIntervalMs = 10; constexpr int64_t kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs = 500 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs; class TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest : public ::testing::TestWithParam { public: TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest() = default; virtual ~TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest() = default; protected: void SendPackets(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker* tracker, const std::vector& sequence_numbers, int64_t send_time_interval_ms, bool validate_all = true) { RTC_CHECK_GE(send_time_interval_ms, 0); for (uint16_t sequence_number : sequence_numbers) { tracker->OnPacketAdded(sequence_number, time_ms_); if (validate_all) { tracker->Validate(); } time_ms_ += send_time_interval_ms; } // We've either validated after each packet, or, for making sure the UT // doesn't run too long, we might validate only at the end of the range. if (!validate_all) { tracker->Validate(); } } void SendPackets(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker* tracker, uint16_t first_seq_num, size_t num_of_packets, int64_t send_time_interval_ms, bool validate_all = true) { RTC_CHECK_GE(send_time_interval_ms, 0); std::vector sequence_numbers(num_of_packets); std::iota(sequence_numbers.begin(), sequence_numbers.end(), first_seq_num); SendPackets(tracker, sequence_numbers, send_time_interval_ms, validate_all); } void AdvanceClock(int64_t time_delta_ms) { RTC_CHECK_GT(time_delta_ms, 0); time_ms_ += time_delta_ms; } void AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate( TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker* tracker, uint16_t base_sequence_num, const std::vector& reception_status_vec) { // Any positive integer signals reception. kNotReceived signals loss. // Other values are just illegal. constexpr int64_t kArrivalTimeMs = 1234; std::vector packet_feedback_vector; uint16_t seq_num = base_sequence_num; for (bool received : reception_status_vec) { packet_feedback_vector.emplace_back(PacketFeedback( received ? kArrivalTimeMs : PacketFeedback::kNotReceived, seq_num)); ++seq_num; } tracker->OnPacketFeedbackVector(packet_feedback_vector); tracker->Validate(); } // Checks that validty is as expected. If valid, checks also that // value is as expected. void ValidatePacketLossStatistics( const TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker& tracker, absl::optional expected_plr, absl::optional expected_rplr) { // TODO(eladalon): Comparing the absl::optional directly would have // given concise code, but less readable error messages. If we modify // the way absl::optional is printed, we can get rid of this. absl::optional plr = tracker.GetPacketLossRate(); EXPECT_EQ(static_cast(expected_plr), static_cast(plr)); if (expected_plr && plr) { EXPECT_EQ(*expected_plr, *plr); } absl::optional rplr = tracker.GetRecoverablePacketLossRate(); EXPECT_EQ(static_cast(expected_rplr), static_cast(rplr)); if (expected_rplr && rplr) { EXPECT_EQ(*expected_rplr, *rplr); } } uint16_t base_{GetParam()}; private: int64_t time_ms_{0}; }; } // namespace // Sanity check on an empty window. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, EmptyWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 5); // PLR and RPLR reported as unknown before reception of first feedback. ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, absl::nullopt, absl::nullopt); } // A feedback received for an empty window has no effect. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, EmptyWindowFeedback) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 3, 2); // Feedback doesn't correspond to any packets - ignored. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, absl::nullopt, absl::nullopt); // After the packets are transmitted, acking them would have an effect. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 3, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f / 3.0f, 0.5f); } // Sanity check on partially filled window. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, PartiallyFilledWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 4); // PLR unknown before minimum window size reached. // RPLR unknown before minimum pairs reached. // Expected window contents: [] -> [1001]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 3, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, absl::nullopt, absl::nullopt); } // Sanity check on minimum filled window - PLR known, RPLR unknown. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, PlrMinimumFilledWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 5); // PLR correctly calculated after minimum window size reached. // RPLR not necessarily known at that time (not if min-pairs not reached). // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, absl::nullopt); } // Sanity check on minimum filled window - PLR unknown, RPLR known. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, RplrMinimumFilledWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 6, 4); // RPLR correctly calculated after minimum pairs reached. // PLR not necessarily known at that time (not if min window not reached). // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, absl::nullopt, 1.0f / 4.0f); } // If packets are sent close enough together that the clock reading for both // is the same, that's handled properly. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, SameSentTime) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 3, 2); // Expected window contents: [] -> [101]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 3, 0); // Note: time interval = 0ms. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f / 3.0f, 0.5f); } // Additional reports update PLR and RPLR. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, ExtendWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 5); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 25, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, absl::nullopt); // Expected window contents: [10011] -> [1001110101]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 5, {true, false, true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 4.0f / 10.0f, 3.0f / 9.0f); // Expected window contents: [1001110101] -> [1001110101-GAP-10001]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 20, {true, false, false, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 7.0f / 15.0f, 4.0f / 13.0f); } // Correct calculation with different packet lengths. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, DifferentSentIntervals) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 4); int64_t frames[] = {20, 60, 120, 20, 60}; for (size_t i = 0; i < sizeof(frames) / sizeof(frames[0]); i++) { SendPackets(&tracker, {static_cast(base_ + i)}, frames[i]); } // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); } // The window retains information up to sent times that exceed the the max // window size. The oldest packets get shifted out of window to make room // for the newer ones. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, MaxWindowSize) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(4 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs, 5, 1); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 6, kDefaultSendIntervalMs, true); // Up to the maximum time-span retained (first + 4 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs). // Expected window contents: [] -> [01001]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {false, true, false, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 5.0f, 2.0f / 4.0f); // After the maximum time-span, older entries are discarded to accommodate // newer ones. // Expected window contents: [01001] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 5, {true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); } // All packets received. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, AllReceived) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 4); // Expected window contents: [] -> [11111]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, true, true, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 0.0f, 0.0f); } // All packets lost. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, AllLost) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 4); // Note: The last packet in the feedback does not belong to the stream. // It's only there because we're not allowed to end a feedback with a loss. // Expected window contents: [] -> [00000]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {false, false, false, false, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f, 0.0f); } // Repeated reports are ignored. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, ReportRepetition) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 4); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Repeat entire previous feedback // Expected window contents: [10011] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); } // Report overlap. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, ReportOverlap) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 1); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 15, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Expected window contents: [10011] -> [1001101]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 3, {true, true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 7.0f, 2.0f / 6.0f); } // Report conflict. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, ReportConflict) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(kDefaultMaxWindowSizeMs, 5, 4); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 15, 10); // Expected window contents: [] -> [01001]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {false, true, false, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 5.0f, 2.0f / 4.0f); // Expected window contents: [01001] -> [11101]. // While false->true will be applied, true -> false will be ignored. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); } // Skipped packets treated as unknown (not lost). TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, SkippedPackets) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(200 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs, 5, 1); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 200, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Expected window contents: [10011] -> [10011-GAP-101]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 100, {true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 8.0f, 2.0f / 6.0f); } // Moving a window, if it excludes some old acked messages, can leave // in-window unacked messages intact, and ready to be used later. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, MovedWindowRetainsRelevantInfo) { constexpr int64_t max_window_size_ms = 100; TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(max_window_size_ms, 5, 1); // Note: All messages in this test are sent 1ms apart from each other. // Therefore, the delta in sequence numbers equals the timestamps delta. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 4 * max_window_size_ms, 1); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10101]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 2.0f / 4.0f); // Expected window contents: [10101] -> [100011]. const int64_t moved_oldest_acked = base_ + 2 * max_window_size_ms; const std::vector feedback = {true, false, false, false, true, true}; AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, moved_oldest_acked, feedback); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 6.0f, 1.0f / 5.0f); // Having acked |feedback.size()| starting with |moved_oldest_acked|, the // newest of the acked ones is now: const int64_t moved_newest_acked = moved_oldest_acked + feedback.size() - 1; // Messages that *are* more than the span-limit away from the newest // acked message *are* too old. Acking them would have no effect. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate( &tracker, moved_newest_acked - max_window_size_ms - 1, {true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 6.0f, 1.0f / 5.0f); // Messages that are *not* more than the span-limit away from the newest // acked message are *not* too old. Acking them would have an effect. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate( &tracker, moved_newest_acked - max_window_size_ms, {true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 7.0f, 1.0f / 5.0f); } // Inserting feedback into the middle of a window works correctly - can // complete two pairs. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, InsertionCompletesTwoPairs) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(150 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs, 5, 1); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 15, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10111]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, true, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Expected window contents: [10111] -> [10111-GAP-10101]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 7, {true, false, true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 3.0f / 10.0f, 3.0f / 8.0f); // Insert in between, closing the gap completely. // Expected window contents: [10111-GAP-10101] -> [101110110101]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 5, {false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 4.0f / 12.0f, 4.0f / 11.0f); } // Sequence number gaps are not gaps in reception. However, gaps in reception // are still possible, if a packet which WAS sent on the stream is not acked. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, SanityGapsInSequenceNumbers) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(50 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs, 5, 1); SendPackets( &tracker, {static_cast(base_), static_cast(base_ + 2), static_cast(base_ + 4), static_cast(base_ + 6), static_cast(base_ + 8)}, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); // Gaps in sequence numbers not considered as gaps in window, because only // those sequence numbers which were associated with the stream count. // Expected window contents: [] -> [11011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate( // Note: Left packets belong to this stream, right ones ignored. &tracker, base_, {true, false, true, false, false, false, true, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Create gap by sending [base + 10] but not acking it. // Note: Acks for [base + 11] and [base + 13] ignored (other stream). // Expected window contents: [11011] -> [11011-GAP-01]. SendPackets( &tracker, {static_cast(base_ + 10), static_cast(base_ + 12), static_cast(base_ + 14)}, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_ + 11, {false, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 7.0f, 2.0f / 5.0f); } // The window cannot span more than 0x8000 in sequence numbers, regardless // of time stamps and ack/unacked status. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, MaxUnackedPackets) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(0x10000, 4, 1); SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 0x2000, 1, false); // Expected window contents: [] -> [10011]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {true, false, false, true, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Sending more unacked packets, up to 0x7fff from the base, does not // move the window or discard any information. SendPackets(&tracker, static_cast(base_ + 0x8000 - 0x2000), 0x2000, 1, false); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 1.0f / 4.0f); // Sending more unacked packets, up to 0x7fff from the base, does not // move the window or discard any information. // Expected window contents: [10011] -> [0011]. SendPackets(&tracker, static_cast(base_ + 0x8000), 1, 1); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 4.0f, 1.0f / 3.0f); } // The window holds acked packets up until the difference in timestamps between // the oldest and newest reaches the configured maximum. Once this maximum // is exceeded, old packets are shifted out of window until the maximum is // once again observed. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, TimeDifferenceMaximumObserved) { constexpr int64_t max_window_size_ms = 500; TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(max_window_size_ms, 3, 1); // Note: All messages in this test are sent 1ms apart from each other. // Therefore, the delta in sequence numbers equals the timestamps delta. // Baseline - window has acked messages. // Expected window contents: [] -> [01101]. const std::vector feedback = {false, true, true, false, true}; SendPackets(&tracker, base_, feedback.size(), 1); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, feedback); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 2.0f / 4.0f); // Test - window base not moved. // Expected window contents: [01101] -> [011011]. AdvanceClock(max_window_size_ms - feedback.size()); SendPackets(&tracker, static_cast(base_ + feedback.size()), 1, 1); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate( &tracker, static_cast(base_ + feedback.size()), {true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 6.0f, 2.0f / 5.0f); // Another packet, sent 1ms later, would already be too late. The window will // be moved, but only after the ACK is received. const uint16_t new_packet_seq_num = static_cast(base_ + feedback.size() + 1); SendPackets(&tracker, {new_packet_seq_num}, 1); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 6.0f, 2.0f / 5.0f); // Expected window contents: [011011] -> [110111]. AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, new_packet_seq_num, {true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 1.0f / 6.0f, 1.0f / 5.0f); } TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, RepeatedSeqNumResetsWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(50 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs, 2, 1); // Baseline - window has acked messages. // Expected window contents: [] -> [01101]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {false, true, true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 2.0f / 4.0f); // A reset occurs. SendPackets(&tracker, {static_cast(base_ + 2)}, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, absl::nullopt, absl::nullopt); } // The window is reset by the sending of a packet which is 0x8000 or more // away from the newest packet acked/unacked packet. TEST_P(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, SendAfterLongSuspensionResetsWindow) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(50 * kDefaultSendIntervalMs, 2, 1); // Baseline - window has acked messages. // Expected window contents: [] -> [01101]. SendPackets(&tracker, base_, 5, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); AddTransportFeedbackAndValidate(&tracker, base_, {false, true, true, false, true}); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, 2.0f / 5.0f, 2.0f / 4.0f); // A reset occurs. SendPackets(&tracker, {static_cast(base_ + 5 + 0x8000)}, kDefaultSendIntervalMs); ValidatePacketLossStatistics(tracker, absl::nullopt, absl::nullopt); } #if RTC_DCHECK_IS_ON && GTEST_HAS_DEATH_TEST && !defined(WEBRTC_ANDROID) TEST(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, InvalidConfigMaxWindowSize) { EXPECT_DEATH(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(0, 20, 10), ""); } TEST(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, InvalidConfigPlrMinAcked) { EXPECT_DEATH(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(5000, 0, 10), ""); } TEST(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, InvalidConfigRplrMinPairs) { EXPECT_DEATH(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(5000, 20, 0), ""); } TEST(TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, TimeCantFlowBackwards) { TransportFeedbackPacketLossTracker tracker(5000, 2, 1); tracker.OnPacketAdded(100, 0); tracker.OnPacketAdded(101, 2); EXPECT_DEATH(tracker.OnPacketAdded(102, 1), ""); } #endif // All tests are run multiple times with various baseline sequence number, // to weed out potential bugs with wrap-around handling. constexpr uint16_t kBases[] = {0x0000, 0x3456, 0xc032, 0xfffe}; INSTANTIATE_TEST_SUITE_P(_, TransportFeedbackPacketLossTrackerTest, ::testing::ValuesIn(kBases)); } // namespace webrtc